a.k.a. my baby brother (though, at 19, I doubt I can still call you a baby):
You deserve better than this.
Ten years ago or so, I wrote you a similar letter (that I never actually sent) because I was afraid for your physical safety. I felt horribly guilty for having an escape route, while you were stuck in the cycle of abuse, at once a victim, an enabler, and occasionally (and, unintentionally) a perpetrator.
Now, I am no longer afraid for your physical safety. You are big enough to take care of yourself, and I know we can add “protector” to your list of roles in this cycle. I’m afraid for your future, or your lack thereof.
Please, go to college. If you won’t move out and away from this dead end town, at least go to college while you live here. Making $13.50 under the table sounds like a good idea for now, but you’re smarter than that. I know you think that you aren’t, but you are. I’m not saying go to university and get some useless undergraduate degree; go to college, or get into a trade, but please just aspire to more than working on an assembly line at the local car manufacturing plant. You know that you can move in with us, and go to college in our city, which is so much more than just a one-intersection town in the backwoods of nowhere.
I know that right now you see nothing wrong with smoking pot by yourself in your parents basement on a Monday night (like you are right now, shamefully hiding it whenever you hear me walk by the stairs, afraid that I’ll walk down and see you). But I know where you are going. You will end up just like him. You will find a girl, and not knowing how to truly love someone because you were never truly and and appropriately loved yourself, you will end up hurting her. And, you will probably hate yourself for it, but you won’t be able to stop yourself because that’s all that you know. And I don’t think that your past as a victim necessarily means you will become a perpetrator, but your unwillingness to even acknowledge that wrong has been done to you just goes to show that you don’t even recognize that there is a problem. You are headed down a very sad and lonely path, and the greatest shame of it all is that you have other options but you’re just too goddamn lazy to take them. And, she won’t let you. Your own mother would rather you stay here and rot with her in this house, all because she is too afraid to be alone and too selfish to admit she has a problem.
I won’t be back. I can’t do this anymore. I refuse to pretend that there is anything “OK” and “normal” about this. I don’t care what you think about me. She will yell at me: “You think you’re so much better than us, don’t you?” And for once, I will be honest. Yes, I do, because I am. I am so much better than this. I am so much better than cigarette stained holes-punched-in-them walls and piece of shit beds with the same blanket that I had when I was growing up. Don’t tell me that you don’t have any money. You have money for beer, and cigarettes, and crappy food that you buy in bulk whenever it’s on sale, and cheap Christmas presents that nobody wants. Have some self respect. I am better than this. I want more than this for myself, and I will not come back again to sit for hours wishing that I could leave. I have NOTHING in common with this place, this way of life, or with any of you.
The only reason I have stayed even remotely attached to any of this is because of you, and because of the years and years of guilt that I carry because I could escape what you never will. Because part of me still, to this day, believes that I can actually save you. I remember being a teenager and brainstorming ways that I could actually take you away from all of this; I wanted to save you so. badly. But I couldn’t, and I can’t, and the sooner I let that go, the better it will be for me. You have to save yourself. And I have to get over the fact that you never will, because this is your “normal”. You just don’t know any other way, and that’s a shame.
Because the world is so much more beautiful than this. You could be so much happier, and realize so much more of your own potential if you only opened your eyes and allowed yourself to dream bigger, and to want more.
I’m sorry, but I hope that one day you will be able to forgive me.
Love always,
Your big sister.